Neighbour’s House for Sale? How to Still Sell Successfully

Written by Dan Attana

March 21, 2025

neighbour's house

Seeing a “For Sale” sign pop up next door can be unsettling. Will your neighbour’s house draw away potential buyers? Will they compare your home unfavourably? It’s a common concern, but with the right approach, you can still sell your home effectively.

Understanding the Challenges of a Neighbour’s House Listing

It’s true that your neighbour’s house being on the market presents some challenges:

  • Buyers will naturally compare your property against your neighbour’s house, seeking the best value.
  • If your neighbour’s house is priced significantly lower, it can affect your listing price.
  • Potential buyers might experience “showing fatigue” from viewing both properties.
  • Buyers might perceive an oversupply of homes in the neighbourhood.

Turning Competition into Opportunity

While challenges exist, opportunities arise:

  • Your neighbour’s house being listed can increase buyer traffic in the area.
  • Two listings can generate more neighbourhood interest than one.
  • This is your chance to showcase your home’s unique features.

Strategies for Success

Here’s how to navigate this situation effectively:

  1. Strategic Pricing:

    • Work with your agent on a comparative market analysis (CMA), considering the pricing of the house next door.
    • Adjust your price accordingly, highlighting your home’s strengths.
    • Don’t automatically undercut, but be realistic.
  2. Highlight Your Home’s Unique Selling Points:

    • What sets your home apart from your neighbour’s house?
    • Emphasize these features in your listing and showings.
    • Stage your home to showcase its best qualities.
  3. Maximize Curb Appeal:

    • Ensure your home’s exterior is immaculate.
    • Landscaping, fresh paint, and a clean entryway make a difference.
  4. Excellent Presentation:

    • Use professional photography and virtual tours.
    • Ensure your home is clean, organized, and well-lit.
  5. Coordinate with Your Agent:

    • Discuss your concerns and develop a strategy.
    • Monitor the other listing.
    • Consider communicating with your neighbour’s agent.
  6. Be Flexible with Showings:

    • Offer flexible showing times.
    • Consider hosting an open house.
  7. Focus on the Neighbourhood:

    • Highlight the neighbourhood’s amenities.
    • Show the advantages of the location.

The Bottom Line

Your neighbour’s house being for sale doesn’t have to hinder your sale. By focusing on strategic pricing, highlighting your home’s unique features, and working with your agent, you can achieve your real estate goals.

To buy or sell your home in Toronto or the Greater Toronto Area, contact me today at 647-995-3391 or via email at [email protected]. You can also visit my website by clicking here.

Please follow and like us:

Questions? Call Dan! : 647 995 3391

Curious about Pre-Construction?

Pre-construction refers to buying properties before they’re physically built. Allure Condos

Click below to learn more about the pro’s and cons of investing in Pre-Construction!

Related Articles

Foreclosure: When Homeownership Faces Hardship

Foreclosure: When Homeownership Faces Hardship

The dream of owning a home is a powerful one, but sometimes, unforeseen circumstances can make it difficult for homeowners to keep up with their mortgage payments. When this happens, the lender may initiate a legal process called foreclosure. It's a term that can...

A Reminder From Your Real Estate Friend

A Reminder From Your Real Estate Friend

Hi friend! As the weather warms up and thoughts might be turning to new beginnings – maybe even a new home? – I just wanted to send a friendly reminder your way. You know me! Beyond the brunch dates, the movie nights, and the witty banter, there's another important...

A Reminder From Your Real Estate Friend

A Reminder From Your Real Estate Friend

Hi friend! As the weather warms up and thoughts might be turning to new beginnings – maybe even a new home? – I just wanted to send a friendly reminder your way. You know me! Beyond the brunch dates, the movie nights, and the witty banter, there's another important...